Thursday, October 13, 2011

Affective Dimensions of Writing


The first writing experience I really remember was in 2nd grade when, for an assignment, we were asked to write a short fictional story that we would then have to read in front of the class. Mine ended up being about a small alien that ended up stealing my mom’s Paul Mitchell hairspray to refuel his space ship with. As horrible of a storyline as that sounds, my classmates ate it up. I still clearly remember the satisfaction I’d experience each time I read an intentionally humorous passage and, in response, hear my peers' appreciative laughter. No New York Times bestselling author has felt more beloved or admired than I did during that reading. I so thoroughly enjoyed this experience, and the praise I received afterward from fellow classmates, that I not only somehow convinced my teacher to let me give another reading of a story I decided to write later that week (an equally engrossing tale in which my classmates and I built a time machine, boarded the Titanic and bribed the captain to not drive so fast with a Milky Way bar—thus saving thousands of lives), but then changed my “What do you want to be when you grow up?” response from “marine biologist for dolphins” to “writer." 

While my 2nd grade aspirations of writing best-selling fictional novels faded almost as quickly as they had started-up, my identity as a writer has continued to develop. My days are almost always packed with writing: from text messages, emails, and Facebook posts to analytical essays and lesson plans for my classes to personal journal entries. I love being a writer--not because I am particularly "good" at it, but as was mentioned in class the other day, that writing allows us to do many things: "to remember, to express, to organize, to communicate and to connect." For these reasons, I am definitely looking forward to teaching my students about writing. 


While my 2nd grade experience with writing was positive, I've definitely experienced a few bad experiences with writing in school since then. And while many factors have contributed to this, the two that stand out the most two me are 1) lack of direction and 2) lack of applicability. Some of the worst experiences I've ever had with writing occurred because the paper requirements and/or rubric weren't detailed or clear enough. Not only do the instructions, rubric and teacher expectations all need to match, but be presented in a way that students clearly understand what is being asked and how to go about it. On the other hand, having to write papers on topics that I felt absolutely no connection to (i.e. a 12th-grade research paper about Type I Diabetes) made writing, in those moments, a mind-numbingly dull and tedious chore that I would dread, procrastinate, finally toss out the night before it was due, and then never want to look at again. As a teacher, I (among other things) want to be sure to always give my students clear explanations of what will be expected from their writing and never force them to write on topics that don't have some relevance to their lives.

2 comments:

  1. I love the idea of that alien using hairspray as ship fuel storyline! That is something I would love to read, even at this point in my life. I think that would make a great children's book if fully written out.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Like Brian, I, too, loved the idea of the Paul Mitchell hairspray line. I hope that you still kept that story.

    The rest of your posting reminded me of a tension in teaching: our need to allow students to have choices in what they write about versus our need to teach a curriculum with standards that are prescribed by state and national standards. In other words, maybe your science teacher really DOES need you to write about body systems, even though those subjects may be boring to some students. So how do you try to build students' interests in those cases? Maybe give them choices AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE, or try to build interest in that subject first before asking students to write about it.

    I think the great thing about your discipline (English) is that you have waaaaay more latitude in letting students choose subjects because your standards are primarily related to form (e.g., write using vivid word choice) and not content (write about the causes of the Civil War). If any discipline really has the greatest potential to spark students' love for writing, it's yours.

    ReplyDelete